
Originally published 2021. Updated September 2026 with current research.
If you have made it through Parts 1 and 2 of this series, you may be looking at your glass of water a little differently.
We have talked about contaminants that can be present in tap water, including lead, PFAS, fluoride, and disinfection byproducts. We have also talked about why bottled water is not necessarily the simple solution it appears to be, especially as we learn more about microplastics and nanoplastics.
So naturally, the next question is: What are we actually supposed to drink?
For my family, the answer has been filtration. But choosing a water filter is not as simple as searching for “the best water filter” and buying whatever comes up first. Different filtration technologies remove different contaminants, and a system that works beautifully in one home may not be the right fit in another.
The goal is not to find the most expensive or elaborate system available. It is to understand your water, know what you are trying to reduce, and choose a system that has actually been tested to do that.

Start with your water, not the filter
Before shopping for a filtration system, I would first ask: What am I actually trying to remove?
That answer can look very different from one household to another. Someone on municipal water may be primarily concerned about chlorine, disinfection byproducts, PFAS, lead, or fluoride. Someone with a private well may be dealing with a completely different set of concerns, such as bacteria, arsenic, nitrates, iron, or hardness.
This is why I always think it makes more sense to start with your water than with a product.
If you are on municipal water, your local Consumer Confidence Report is a helpful starting point. It can tell you where your water comes from and which contaminants have been detected. But as we talked about in Part 1, that report reflects the water system as a whole. It does not necessarily tell you exactly what is coming out of your kitchen faucet after the water has passed through service lines, household plumbing, and fixtures.
If you live in an older home, use a private well, know of local contamination issues, or simply want a clearer picture, actual home water testing can be incredibly helpful.
Once you know what you are trying to reduce, choosing a filter becomes much easier.
Look for actual testing, not impressive marketing
This is probably one of the biggest things I want people to understand when shopping for a water filter.
A company can tell you its system has “12 stages,” produces “pure water,” or “removes toxins,” but those phrases do not actually tell you whether the filter removes the contaminant you care about.
I want to see independent testing or certification tied to specific contaminant-reduction claims.
This is where NSF standards can be useful. NSF/ANSI 42 generally addresses things like chlorine, taste, and odor. NSF/ANSI 53 covers certain contaminants that may have health effects, such as lead, depending on the specific product certification. NSF/ANSI 58 applies to reverse-osmosis systems and may include reduction claims for contaminants such as lead, arsenic, fluoride, nitrate, and others.
But the standard number alone is not enough. You still want to look at what that exact model has been tested or certified to reduce.
A filter certified for chlorine reduction is not automatically certified for lead. A system that reduces lead is not automatically designed to remove fluoride or PFAS.
That is why I care much more about the actual performance data than how many filtration stages are printed on the box.
Activated carbon filters
Activated carbon is one of the most common forms of home water filtration.
Carbon has a large porous surface that adsorbs certain compounds as water passes through it. It is commonly used to reduce chlorine, improve taste and odor, and reduce some organic contaminants.
This is the type of filtration found in many refrigerator filters, pitchers, faucet-mounted systems, and more advanced multi-stage systems.
Carbon can also be effective for some PFAS compounds, depending on the filter design, contact time, and certification. EPA currently lists granular activated carbon as one of the technologies that can be effective at reducing PFAS in drinking water.
But carbon is not a universal filter.
A basic refrigerator or pitcher filter may primarily be designed to improve taste and reduce chlorine. It may not reduce fluoride, dissolved salts, nitrates, or every heavy metal you are concerned about.
Again, this is why I care more about the specific reduction claims than the words “carbon filter” on the box.

Reverse osmosis
Reverse osmosis, or RO, is one of the broadest point-of-use filtration options available for the home.
RO systems use pressure to push water through a semipermeable membrane, separating the treated water from a concentrated waste stream. Depending on the system and certification, RO can reduce a wide range of contaminants, including lead, arsenic, fluoride, dissolved solids, some PFAS, and certain other inorganic and organic contaminants.
RO also removes a significant amount of dissolved minerals, including calcium and magnesium. Since RO is very effective at removing minerals, it is necessary to add in essential minerals to replace lost minerals and so that water may be effectively absorbed and used in the body.
RO does have drawbacks. It creates a waste stream, requires filter and membrane replacement, and some systems need more under-sink space. Newer systems are often more water efficient than older models, so efficiency is another specification worth comparing. EPA now even has a WaterSense specification for point-of-use RO systems designed to reduce unnecessary water waste.
Sediment filtration
Sediment filters are relatively simple, but they can be incredibly useful as the first stage of a larger system.
They physically trap suspended particles such as sand, rust, dirt, and other debris. What they generally do not do is remove dissolved chemicals simply because those chemicals are smaller than the filter pore size.
I like to think of sediment filtration as protecting the rest of the system. Removing larger particles first can improve performance and extend the life of downstream carbon filters or membranes. This can be especially useful with well water or homes with visible sediment issues.
Ion exchange and specialty media
Some filters use ion-exchange resins or specialty adsorptive media to target specific contaminants.
Ion exchange can be used for things such as hardness, nitrate, or certain PFAS compounds depending on the resin.
Activated alumina is another specialty medium that has historically been used to reduce fluoride and arsenic.
These are not necessarily technologies I would select in isolation without knowing what is in the water. They are useful precisely because they can target particular problems.
For example, EPA currently lists ion-exchange resins alongside activated carbon and reverse osmosis as technologies that may be effective for reducing PFAS.
This is another reason multi-stage systems can make sense: one treatment method may address something another stage does not.

What about UV?
Ultraviolet treatment is different because UV is a disinfectant, not really a chemical filter.
UV systems expose water to ultraviolet light to inactivate microorganisms. This can be incredibly useful in situations where bacteria, viruses, or other microorganisms are a concern, particularly with certain private wells.
But UV does not remove lead, PFAS, fluoride, arsenic, or most dissolved chemicals. That means UV is usually used alongside filtration rather than instead of it.
The CDC makes the same distinction: different systems address different contaminants, and treatment for microorganisms does not necessarily address chemicals.
Point-of-use or whole-house filtration?
Another decision is whether you want to treat only the water you drink and cook with or the water entering your entire home.
A point-of-use system treats water at one location, usually the kitchen sink. Under-sink RO systems, countertop filters, gravity systems, and pitchers all fall into this category.
A point-of-entry system, often called whole-house filtration, treats water as it enters the home.
If your biggest concern is what you are ingesting, treating the kitchen water may be enough. But if you also want to reduce things like chlorine or sediment throughout the house, including the water used for showers, baths, laundry, and appliances, a whole-house system may make more sense.
Your living situation matters too. Renters may need a countertop or removable system that can move with them, while homeowners may decide a more permanent setup is worth the investment.
There is no one right answer. The better question is which setup makes sense for your actual home and water.

What about shower and bath water?
Exposure from shower water can happen through a combination of inhalation, skin contact, and the volatile disinfection byproducts that can enter indoor air during showering.
For a family that wants to reduce chlorine exposure throughout the home, a whole-house carbon system can be a more comprehensive option. Shower filters may also help, but their effectiveness varies, especially because chlorine and chloramine are not equally easy to remove.
Water softeners are not the same thing as water filters
This distinction causes a lot of confusion.
Water softeners are designed primarily to address hardness minerals such as calcium and magnesium. They can be incredibly helpful if you are dealing with scale buildup, hard-water residue, or appliance issues.
But softened water is not automatically filtered water.
A water softener does not necessarily remove PFAS, chlorine, lead, fluoride, or other contaminants you may be concerned about. Some homes need both a softener and a separate filtration system.
Our family’s approach has changed over the years
At one point, we owned a home where we could install a whole-house system along with under-sink reverse osmosis. At another point, we were renting, so permanent plumbing changes did not make sense and we relied more heavily on removable or countertop filtration.
That is how I encourage people to think about this.
You do not have to buy your forever filtration system today. Start with the situation you are actually in.
What does your water contain? Are you renting or owning? Do you need drinking-water filtration only, or do you also want whole-house treatment? How much water does your family use? What fits your budget? And perhaps most importantly, what can you realistically maintain?
Because maintenance matters just as much as the filter itself.
A wonderful filtration system with an exhausted cartridge is no longer doing what you bought it to do.
What I would look for in a filter today
If I were choosing a new system today, I would want clear answers to a few basic questions.
What contaminants am I trying to reduce? Has this exact model been independently tested or certified for those contaminants? Which standards does it meet, and what specific reduction claims are included? What is the filter capacity and replacement schedule? How much will replacement cartridges cost over the course of a year? Does the system actually fit our household size and water use? If it is reverse osmosis, how efficient is it and how much reject water does it produce? And most importantly, can I realistically keep up with maintaining it?
Those questions will tell you much more than whether a system has five stages or fifteen.
There is no perfect filter
I think this is the most important way to end this series.
There is no single water filter that is automatically best for every family.
The right system depends on your source water, the contaminants present, your home, your budget, your family size, and your priorities. A countertop system may be exactly what a renter needs. Someone with a contaminated private well may need something much more comprehensive. Another family may decide that whole-house carbon plus an under-sink RO system gives them the balance they want.
The goal is not to chase the most elaborate setup.
The goal is to know what is in your water and choose a system that is actually proven to reduce what you do not want there.
After everything we have talked about throughout this series, that is really where I land.
I cannot control every exposure my family encounters. But water is something we use every single day, and filtration is one of the areas where we can make a practical, meaningful change.
Continue the Clean Water Series
Part 1: How Clean Is Your Drinking Water? What to Know About Common Tap Water Contaminants
Part 1 looks at chlorine byproducts, fluoride, lead, PFAS, plumbing, and why water can meet regulatory standards while still containing things you may want to reduce.
Part 2: Microplastics in Bottled Water: Is Bottled Water Really Cleaner?
Part 2 looks at bottled water, microplastics, nanoplastics, and why plastic bottles are not necessarily the cleaner alternative.
Part 3: Water Filtration at Home: How to Choose the Right Filter for Your Family